Why Orioles’ Top Prospect Jackson Holliday Will Start in Minors, Explained by GM

So, the Baltimore Orioles made a move that kinda shook things up a bit. They sent Jackson Holliday, their star middle infielder, packing off to the minors last Friday. This pretty much squashed any dreams of him starting the season in the major leagues. Mike Elias, the top dog in baseball operations, had folks buzzing over the winter. He hinted that Holliday had a solid shot at making it big from the get-go.

Now, let’s talk about Holliday. The guy’s only 20, but CBS Sports is already calling him the No. 1 prospect. Why? Well, he’s got an offensive game that’s way ahead of the curve, and he’s slick in the middle of the field. His spring performance? Not too shabby. He batted .311, slugged .600, and even knocked two homers out of the park. Plus, he snagged a couple of bases. But, it wasn’t all roses. His strikeout-to-walk ratio was a bit of an eyesore – 15 strikeouts with just three walks in 48 plate appearances.

After the Orioles made their decision, Elias spent a good chunk of time explaining the move to reporters. Jacob Calvin Meyer from the Baltimore Sun got it all down, noting the explanation was a hefty one, over 750 words. In a nutshell, Elias believes Holliday is “very, very close.” Yet, his lack of experience against tough lefties and not enough defensive plays at second base played a big part in the decision.

Elias pointed out that Holliday’s rapid rise and limited pro experience meant he hadn’t faced many quality left-handed pitchers. This is crucial, especially in the American League East, where facing top-notch southpaws is inevitable. Last season, Holliday faced lefties in just 124 of his plate appearances, and his OPS against them wasn’t as impressive as against righties. Plus, he’s only logged 25 appearances at second base.

It seems the Orioles have plenty of infield talent to tide them over while Holliday hones his skills in Triple-A. This move might have been somewhat expected, given the Orioles’ history with top prospects. Yet, it does raise eyebrows concerning the Prospect Promotion Incentive (PPI) system in the new Collective Bargaining Agreement. This system rewards teams for not holding back their top rookies, offering a draft pick for those who win Rookie of the Year after a full season in the majors.

Holliday ticked the first two boxes for the PPI, making the Orioles’ decision even more intriguing. They must really believe he needs more seasoning in the minors. Or maybe, just maybe, they’re not sweating over a draft pick. Regardless, we’re all eager to see Holliday’s major league debut, which should be happening this season.

And hey, the Orioles’ season kicks off on March 28 against the Los Angeles Angels. Let’s see how things unfold without Holliday on the roster.

Joshua Collins
Joshua Collins
Joshua Collins is a Senior Writer for BaseballHype.com. With a profound passion for baseball and a diverse background in Sports Media, Joshua joined the team in 2023. As an avid fan of the game, he brings an insightful perspective and an uncanny ability to dissect the intricate details of baseball. Joshua consistently delivers the latest news, engaging features, and game results.

Related Stories