Why David Stearns Bet on Five Pitchers for the Mets During a Quiet Offseason & How It Might Succeed

David Stearns stepping into the New York Mets’ scene didn’t exactly shake the earth. Unlike previous years, where the Mets’ offseasons were akin to fireworks shows, Stearns’ moves have been more… Milwaukee Brewers-like. Up to now, Stearns’ biggest splash was signing Sean Manaea, and even that didn’t break the bank. It’s a stark contrast to the Mets’ recent star-studded acquisitions.

Manaea’s contract? Not exactly headline material, especially when you consider the broader landscape of MLB signings. It’s a curious approach, given Steve Cohen’s usually more flamboyant offseasons. But hey, maybe there’s a method to the madness. Stearns did eye Yoshinobu Yamamoto, hinting he’s not totally averse to big names. Yet, this winter, it seems like the Mets are betting on turning around the fortunes of some underperforming pitchers.

The team’s new pitching squad is a mixed bag of potential and question marks. Severino, López, and Fujinami, for instance, didn’t exactly boast stellar ERAs last year. Manaea and Diekman come with their own sets of doubts. But perhaps there’s a diamond in the rough among them.

1. RHP Luis Severino

Severino’s recent years have been tough, marred by injuries and underperformance. Last season was particularly rough, with an ERA that made him self-deprecatingly call himself “the worst pitcher in the game.” Yet, his underlying stats suggest there’s hope if he can just stay healthy.

2. LHP Sean Manaea

Manaea’s had his ups and downs, with last year starting off on the wrong foot. However, a mid-season turnaround gave a glimpse of what he’s capable of. Adjustments to his game brought about a notable improvement. The question is, can he keep it up?

3. RHP Jorge López

Remember López’s All-Star moment? Last year wasn’t it, but the Mets see something in him. His arsenal, including a potent sinker, could find new life in New York. Maybe, just maybe, the Mets can unlock his potential.

4. LHP Jake Diekman

Diekman’s age might be creeping up, but his arm seems unaware. Despite control issues, he’s remained a strikeout machine. Last year, he added a changeup to his repertoire, showing he can still evolve. It’s a gamble, but one that could pay off.

5. RHP Shintaro Fujinami

Fujinami’s MLB debut year was rough, to put it mildly. Yet, the Mets are betting on his raw talent, hoping he can refine his command. It’s a critical year for him, with much to prove.

In essence, the Mets’ offseason strategy seems to revolve around high-risk, high-reward pitching bets. It’s a departure from their recent star-chasing winters, but who knows? Maybe Stearns and co. are onto something. Only time will tell if these gambles turn into triumphs or lessons learned.

Joshua Collins
Joshua Collins
Joshua Collins is a Senior Writer for BaseballHype.com. With a profound passion for baseball and a diverse background in Sports Media, Joshua joined the team in 2023. As an avid fan of the game, he brings an insightful perspective and an uncanny ability to dissect the intricate details of baseball. Joshua consistently delivers the latest news, engaging features, and game results.

Related Stories